Food Company Wins Religious Exemption from Contraception Benefit
Fresh Unlimited Inc. won’t have to provide contraceptive coverage for its employees under the Obama administration’s healthcare reform law, in what may be the first exemption granted since a June U.S. Supreme Court ruling.
The parent of Freshway Foods on Friday won an appeals court ruling that qualifies it for the same treatment the high court approved in its June 30 Hobby Lobby decision allowing family-run businesses to claim a religious exemption from the requirement to include contraceptives in their health insurance plans.
The suit by Francis and Philip Gilardi, who own Sidney, Ohio-based Freshway, is one of about 50 filed by for-profit businesses over religious objections to the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010’s birth-control coverage mandate. The Gilardis are Roman Catholic and said that complying with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services mandate would require them to violate deeply held religious beliefs.
U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan in Washington in March 2013 ruled against the Gilardis, saying that he couldn’t allow a corporation to assert the religious beliefs of individuals. The U.S. Court of Appeals reversed part of Sullivan’s decision, and the ruling was put on hold pending the Supreme Court’s resolution of the Hobby Lobby case.
In addition to carving a hole in the law, the Hobby Lobby ruling marked an expansion of corporate rights, allowing companies, like people, to claim religious freedom under federal law.
“To my knowledge, the D.C. Circuit is the first court of appeals to apply Hobby Lobby in a remanded HHS mandate case,” said Adele Keim, an attorney with the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, a Washington-based, nonprofit religion advocacy group which represented Hobby Lobby in its legal challenge.
Today’s order sends the Freshway case back to Sullivan with instructions to issue an order granting an exemption and to consider whether to extend it to the Gilardis.
The case is Gilardi v. HHS, 13-cv-00104, U.S. District Court, District of Columbia (Washington).
- Florida’s Citizens Defends Travel Expenses Questioned By Gov. Scott
- California Insurance Broker Pays Off Lawsuit With Buckets of Coins
- Hawaii Spared Hurricane As Iselle Weakens to Tropical Storm
- Nuisance Flooding Rising Problem for U.S. Cities: NOAA
- Teens Say Parents Ignore Pleas to Stop Texting, Driving Under Influence
- U.S., Rockefeller $100M Fund Promotes Natural Disaster Mitigation, Insurance for Poor
- Soft P/C Market Flattens Independent Agencies’ Organic Growth in Q2: Reagan Consulting
- AIG Reports 12.5% Rise in Profit in Benmosche’s Last Quarter As CEO
via Insurance Journal » News http://ift.tt/1pmumu9
Recent PostsPopular Posts
- Small Businesses to Commercial Insurers: ‘You’ve Lost That Loving Feeling’ August 11, 2014 0 comments
- Salmonella Testing Not Required by Food Safety Law, Georgia Jurors Told August 11, 2014 0 comments
- Food Company Wins Religious Exemption from Contraception Benefit August 11, 2014 0 comments
- West Virginia Seeks $1.8M from Bankrupt Freedom Industries for Spill August 11, 2014 0 comments
- Who’s Worth What in the Independent Agency System? Find Out Now January 22, 2013 0 comments
- S&P: Low Interest Rates, Regulation Issues Are Key Insurance Industry Risks January 23, 2013 0 comments
- Securities Fraud Class Actions Declined in 2012 January 23, 2013 0 comments
- Supreme Court Won’t Hear Retaliation Case Against Sears January 23, 2013 0 comments
- Small Businesses to Commercial Insurers: ‘You’ve Lost That Loving Feeling’
- Salmonella Testing Not Required by Food Safety Law, Georgia Jurors Told
- Food Company Wins Religious Exemption from Contraception Benefit
- West Virginia Seeks $1.8M from Bankrupt Freedom Industries for Spill
- CCRIF/Swiss Re Offer Caribbean Governments Insurance against Excess Rainfall
- Weakened Typhoon Halong Lashes Japan; 1 Dead, Dozens Hurt
- Iranian Passenger Plane Crashes Killing 48
- ABI Says Reducing Whiplash Costs Key to Lower Auto Premiums
- GM Loses Bid to Dismiss Ignition-Switch Defect Cover-Up Claim
- Drought Weakens Links in Supply Chain Metaphor